Section 17 application before the Debts Recovery Tribunal
Section 17 is the main remedy against measures taken by a secured creditor under Section 13(4). It carries a short limitation period.
Who can apply
Any person, including a borrower or guarantor, aggrieved by a measure taken under Section 13(4) may apply to the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT) having jurisdiction. The article on tenants and occupants looks at persons other than the borrower.
The forty-five day limit
The application must be made within forty-five days from the date on which the measure was taken. Which date counts depends on the measure, so the dates should be set against the documents at the outset. Delay can close this remedy.
What the Tribunal examines
The DRT considers whether the measures taken for enforcement of the security are in accordance with the Act and the Rules. Grounds commonly raised include:
- A notice that is defective or does not match the account
- Errors in the classification of the account or the amount claimed
- Non-compliance with Rules 8 and 9 on possession and sale, which the Supreme Court in Mathew Varghese v. M. Amritha Kumar (2014) 5 SCC 610 held must be complied with
- Undervaluation or a reserve price fixed without proper valuation
- Irregularities in the conduct of the auction
Interim relief and deposits
The DRT may grant interim relief, such as a stay of possession or sale. Relief is discretionary and is often made conditional on a deposit. The amount depends on the facts. See interim relief in a Section 17 application.
Timeline and outcome
The Tribunal is expected to decide the application within sixty days, extendable to four months in all, although matters often take longer. If it finds that the measures were not in accordance with the Act and the Rules, it can declare them invalid and restore possession or management to the borrower, or make such other order as it considers appropriate. An order of the DRT can be taken in appeal to the DRAT under Section 18.
Our work at this stage
We prepare and argue Section 17 applications, including applications for interim protection, and advise on the pre-deposit and appeal that may follow. Our article on the Section 17 application and the 45-day limit gives more detail.
Frequently asked questions
What is the time limit for a Section 17 application?
Ordinarily forty-five days from the date on which the measure under Section 13(4) was taken.
Is a pre-deposit required to file a Section 17 application?
The statutory pre-deposit applies to an appeal under Section 18, not to the Section 17 application. Deposits are, however, commonly required as a condition of interim protection. Check the current text of the Act.
Can I file a writ petition in the High Court instead?
The High Court generally expects the statutory remedy before the DRT to be used. In United Bank of India v. Satyawati Tondon (2010) 8 SCC 110 the Supreme Court discouraged writ petitions against SARFAESI action. See High Court writ petitions and SARFAESI.
Will the DRT stop an auction?
That is a matter of discretion on the facts. The Tribunal looks at compliance with the Rules, the valuation and reserve price, and whether payment or settlement is offered.
Related articles
Other practice areas
General information only, not legal advice. Please check the current text of the Act and Rules, which may have been amended.
Received a SARFAESI notice or an auction notice?
Deadlines under the Act are short. Speak to us early so that your options stay open.
Request a consultation