Writ petitions in the High Court against SARFAESI action
The High Court has writ jurisdiction over SARFAESI action, but the Supreme Court has discouraged borrowers from bypassing the statutory remedy.
The general position
Sections 17 and 18 give a borrower or other aggrieved person a remedy before the Debts Recovery Tribunal and then the Appellate Tribunal. In United Bank of India v. Satyawati Tondon (2010) 8 SCC 110, the Supreme Court discouraged High Courts from entertaining writ petitions against SARFAESI action where this statutory remedy is available. The High Court may decline to hear the petition and send the person to the Tribunal.
When a writ is considered
A writ petition is entertained only in limited situations, such as a manifest lack of jurisdiction or a violation of fundamental rights. Whether a case falls in this category depends on its own facts, and it should not be assumed.
Do not treat a writ as a shortcut
The forty-five day period for a Section 17 application should be checked at once. A pending writ petition should not be assumed to protect that period. Where the Tribunal remedy is still available, filing there is usually the safer course.
The Act itself
The Supreme Court considered the validity of the Act in Mardia Chemicals v. Union of India (2004) 4 SCC 311, and recognised the borrower's right to object to a Section 13(2) notice and the creditor's duty to reply with reasons.
Our work at this stage
We assess whether a writ petition before the High Court of Karnataka is available, or whether a Section 17 application is the better course, and prepare the matter accordingly. See also our article on High Court writ petitions and SARFAESI, and the page on appeals before the DRAT.
Frequently asked questions
Can I go directly to the High Court against a SARFAESI notice or auction?
The High Court generally expects the statutory remedy before the DRT to be used first. Writs are entertained only in limited situations.
Will a writ petition stop an auction?
Interim orders are discretionary. The High Court may direct the petitioner to the DRT instead.
Does filing a writ extend the time for a Section 17 application?
That should not be assumed. The limitation position should be checked at once.
Related articles
Other practice areas
General information only, not legal advice. Please check the current text of the Act and Rules, which may have been amended.
Received a SARFAESI notice or an auction notice?
Deadlines under the Act are short. Speak to us early so that your options stay open.
Request a consultation