Receiving a demand notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act 2002 does not leave a borrower without a voice. The Act allows the borrower to raise objections in writing, and the secured creditor is expected to respond with reasons.
Where this comes from
In Mardia Chemicals v. Union of India (2004) 4 SCC 311, the Supreme Court upheld the validity of the Act but recognised that a borrower must be able to object to the notice and that the creditor must reply to those objections with reasons. Parliament later added this safeguard to the Act as Section 13(3A). Check the current text of Section 13(3A) for the exact wording and the time allowed for the bank's reply.
What an objection can cover
A borrower may question the notice on factual or legal grounds, such as:
- the amount claimed is different from the loan account
- the date of NPA classification appears incorrect
- interest or charges seem wrongly applied
- the notice does not describe the secured asset correctly
- the person served is not the correct borrower or guarantor
How to write a useful objection
- Reply in writing within the period stated in the notice, and keep proof of delivery.
- Be specific. Point to the entry, date or figure you dispute instead of making general complaints.
- Attach documents, such as statements, receipts and earlier correspondence.
- Ask for supporting records, such as the account statement and the basis of the NPA date.
- Stay respectful and factual. A clear letter is easier to rely on later.
What the bank's reply means
If the bank considers the objection, it should communicate its reasons for accepting or not accepting it. A reply that gives no reasons, or ignores the points raised, may be useful to point out in later proceedings.
Objection is not the end of the road
If the objections are not accepted and the bank takes a measure under Section 13(4), the borrower can consider a Section 17 application before the Debts Recovery Tribunal within the time limit in the Act. The Supreme Court in United Bank of India v. Satyawati Tondon (2010) 8 SCC 110 discouraged writ petitions against SARFAESI action where such a remedy is available.
Do not ignore the notice
Not replying can weaken your position and may leave you with less on record. The objection should be sent even if you also plan to discuss a settlement with the bank.
Getting advice
Every notice and loan account is different. A prompt review of the papers helps in preparing an objection that is accurate and complete.
General information only, not legal advice. Law may have changed after the date of publication.