Sometimes a secured property sells for more than the amount the borrower owes. A natural question follows: does the borrower get the extra money back? The SARFAESI Act 2002 deals with this in its provisions on how sale money is to be applied.
What the Act says about sale proceeds
Under Section 13(7), money received by a secured creditor from a sale is to be held in trust and applied in a stated order: first to the costs of the sale and incidental expenses, then to the dues of the secured creditor. The residue, if any, is to be paid to the person entitled to it, subject to the Act. Check the current text of Section 13(7) and the Rules for the exact wording.
What this means in plain terms
- The bank may deduct the reasonable costs of the sale.
- It then adjusts the secured debt, including interest and charges that are properly due.
- If anything remains, it should be paid to the borrower or to another person who has a legal right to it, such as a subsequent secured creditor.
When there may be competing claims
A surplus may not always go to the borrower. If another lender or claimant has a charge on the property, that claim may need to be considered first. This is why priority and registration of charges matter, as explained in our post on the Central Registry.
What a borrower should do
- Ask for a sale statement showing the sale price, costs deducted and the amount applied to the loan.
- Compare it with the account statement before the sale.
- Write to the bank asking for the surplus, if any, to be paid, with account details.
- Keep copies of the sale notice, auction result and sale certificate.
- If the bank does not respond, take advice on the proper forum and timeline.
Also consider the shortfall
If the sale price is lower than the dues, the bank may claim the balance through other recovery routes. The Supreme Court in Transcore v. Union of India (2008) 1 SCC 125 held that SARFAESI and the RDB Act operate together, so a shortfall may be pursued that way.
Challenging the sale itself
If the borrower believes the sale was defective, the remedy is a Section 17 application before the Debts Recovery Tribunal within the time in the Act. The Supreme Court in Mathew Varghese v. M. Amritha Kumar (2014) 5 SCC 610 stressed compliance with Rules 8 and 9.
Getting advice
Whether there is a surplus, and who is entitled to it, depends on the sale papers and competing claims. A prompt review helps in making a clear written demand.
General information only, not legal advice. Law may have changed after the date of publication.