The reserve price is the minimum price below which the bank will not sell the property in a SARFAESI auction. Borrowers often feel that the reserve price is too low and ask whether it can be challenged. Such a challenge usually depends on evidence.
How the reserve price is set
Under the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules 2002, the authorised officer of the bank obtains a valuation of the property and fixes a reserve price before the sale. The auction notice must state the details the Rules require. Check the current text of Rules 8 and 9 for the exact steps. The Supreme Court in Mathew Varghese v. M. Amritha Kumar (2014) 5 SCC 610 said that Rules 8 and 9 must be complied with, which gives a borrower a basis to examine the process.
Grounds a borrower may examine
- Was the valuation done by a qualified valuer, and is the report available?
- Does the report describe the correct property, area and location?
- Was the reserve price fixed after the valuation, and is the working shown?
- Was the sale notice issued with the required details and gap in time?
- Was the borrower informed as the Rules require?
Evidence that can help
- An independent valuation report from a registered valuer, prepared close to the date of the auction.
- Registered sale deeds of comparable properties nearby.
- Government circle rates or guideline values, where relevant.
- Photographs and measurements of the property.
- Records of earlier valuations, including the valuation at the time of the loan.
- Copies of all notices, bank letters and emails.
A claim that the price is "too low" without such material is difficult to establish.
Where to raise it
A challenge to a sale conducted under the Act is raised by way of a Section 17 application before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, within the limit in the Act. The Supreme Court in United Bank of India v. Satyawati Tondon (2010) 8 SCC 110 discouraged writ petitions where this remedy is available.
Practical tips
- Act before the auction date, if possible, instead of after the sale.
- Ask the bank in writing for the valuation report and the basis of the reserve price.
- If a better offer is available, put it in writing and share proof of the buyer's capacity.
- Do not rely on informal assurances.
The post on bank auction notices on this blog explains the notice requirements in more detail.
Getting advice
Reserve price disputes turn on valuation evidence and the facts of the sale. An early document review helps in deciding whether a challenge is worth pursuing.
General information only, not legal advice. Law may have changed after the date of publication.